Apache leader: Unite to fight proposed copper mine

Naelyn and Nizhoni Pike participate in the San Carlos Apache Tribe’s “sunrise ceremony” at Oak Flat near Superior. Courtesy of Sandra Rambler

Naelyn and Nizhoni Pike participate in the San Carlos Apache Tribe’s “sunrise ceremony” at Oak Flat near Superior. Courtesy of Sandra Rambler

tucson.com

Apache leader Wendsler Nosie issued a call for solidarity in the fight against Congress’ recent decision to give sacred Native American land to a foreign mining company.

Speaking to a crowd of about 75 gathered Friday in South Tucson, Nosie invited people of of all races, religions and political affiliations to stand up against what he calls the “dirty” way in which legislators approved the land swap in December. He invited everyone to a spiritual gathering and protest at Oak Flat, about 100 miles north of Tucson, next Saturday.

“This is not just our fight. This is an American battle,” said Nosie, former chairman of the San Carlos Apache Tribe. The reservation’s border is just east of the proposed copper mine at Oak Flat, sacred to Western Apache and Yavapai people.

Friday’s event, held at the Global Justice Center in South Tucson, was hosted by Indigenous Alliance Without Borders, which advocates for the rights of indigenous peoples in the borderlands between Mexico and the U.S.

Speakers included representatives from the nonprofit Save the Scenic Santa Ritas and Arizona Mining Reform Coalition.

Since 2005, Resolution Copper Mining — a subsidiary of foreign mining giants Rio Tinto and BHP Billiton Inc. — has been trying to acquire 2,400 acres of Tonto National Forest, which sits above a massive copper deposit, through a legislated land-swap bill. A dozen earlier versions of the stand-alone bill failed to make it through Congress.

But the land swap finally made it through Congress last month, after legislators — led by Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz. — slipped it into the must-pass National Defense Authorization Act.

When Nosie learned the land deal had passed, “the only thing I could do was cry,” he said on Friday. “Our indigenous homelands continue to be taken away.”

SILVER LINING

But opponents say there’s a silver lining to the way the land deal passed: The situation has now gotten national attention, provoking outrage and giving intense momentum to opposition, they say. Opponents intend to continue seeking legal or legislative ways to revoke the land swap.

“It took something devastating to happen for it to get attention,” Standing Fox, a 30-year-old artist, said before Friday’s event. He grew up on the San Carlos Apache reservation and is Chiricahua Apache. He’s been working to organize resistance to the mine proposal for almost a decade. “It’s all about taking the punches and looking to the next step.”

The site of the proposed mine contains areas long held sacred to Native American tribes, as well as recreational sites beloved by birders, hikers and rock climbers.

Oak Flat, known as Chich’il Bildagoteel to the Apache, is the site of ritual collection of acorns and medicinal plants for tribe members, and coming-of-age ceremonies. The San Carlos Apache believe their spiritual beings reside in Oak Flat and in the nearby Queen Creek and Gaan Canyons, which could be dewatered by the mining activity.

Resolution Copper has projected the crater formed on the surface of Oak Flat, resulting from block-cave mining, would be two miles wide and 1,000 feet deep at its center.

MINING COMPANY RESPONSE

Resolution officials said on Friday they are committed to working with the tribes.

“We have been really trying for at least a decade to build a relationship with the San Carlos Apache Tribe to discuss mutual benefits of the project,” including mining jobs that could help alleviate high unemployment on the reservations, said Vicky Peacey, Resolution Copper’s senior manager for environment, permitting and community. “We’ve done a poor job of communicating the potential benefits.”

The company is required to comply with cultural-protection regulations such as the National Historic Preservation Act and Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, she said.

“Tribes with interest in the project must be consulted through the whole process,” she said. “We will look for ways to avoid, minimize and — if we can’t do that — mitigate, cooperatively with tribe’s input, the impact of the project.”

But tribe members, as well as U.S. Secretary of the Interior Sally Jewell, have said that tribes should have been consulted before the land swap gave away Native Americans’ ancestral lands to a private company.

The latest version of the land exchange prohibits mining under the culturally significant cliffs at Apache Leap, but opponents say the mining company can’t guarantee it won’t be affected.

The legislation also guarantees that Native American tribes can continue to visit Oak Flat until it becomes too dangerous. That will likely be more than a decade from now, Peacey said.

All Nations Spiritual Gathering

Tribal leaders and activists will host a “Gathering of Nations” at Oak Flat Campground on Saturday, Feb. 7.

The event will be the culmination of a two-day protest march, led by San Carlos Apache leaders, starting in San Carlos, Ariz., and ending at Oak Flat. The march will begin on Thursday, Feb. 5 at 9:30 a.m., at the tribal offices in downtown San Carlos, at 11 San Carlos Ave.

For details, contact apache.stronghold@gmail.com or call 982-475-2930.

Obama administration’s opposition

In a December statement, U.S. Secretary of the Interior Sally Jewell said she was “profoundly disappointed” in the land-swap’s inclusion in the defense authorization act. Its passage “short circuits the long-standing and fundamental practice of pursuing meaningful government-to-government consultation with the 566 federally recognized tribes with whom we have a unique legal and trust responsibility.”

“Although there are consultation requirements in the legislation, the appropriate time for honoring our government-to-government relationship with tribes is before legislating issues of this magnitude,” the statement said. “The tribe’s sacred land has now been placed in great jeopardy.”

Violent Standoff Continues at Myanmar Mine Protest (Video)

News / Asia

Violence is continuing at a copper mine in Myanmar, also known as Burma, as protesters continue a standoff with security forces over plans to expand the mine.

At least two people were hurt in clashes Tuesday, one day after one person was killed and 20 were injured in violence at the Letpadaung mine in the northern part of the country.

According to activists and opposition lawmakers, a woman was fatally shot Monday during a crackdown on protesters at the controversial Chinese-backed copper mine near Monywa in northwestern Myanmar, Dec. 22, 2014.

According to activists and opposition lawmakers, a woman was fatally shot Monday during a crackdown on protesters at the controversial Chinese-backed copper mine near Monywa in northwestern Myanmar, Dec. 22, 2014.

A local resident who did not want to be named told VOA’s Burmese service that protesters were continuing their campaign to stop mine expansion that would force villagers to be relocated.

In the early morning, around 2,000 members of security forces and Wan Bao security guards attempted to fence off land for the mining project, and local villagers went there to stop the attempt. Two villagers were seriously injured in shooting that ensued,” said the resident.

Police at the Letpadaung Copper Mine in northern Myanmar prepare for a confrontation with protesters, Dec. 22, 2014. (photographer unknown)

Police at the Letpadaung Copper Mine in northern Myanmar prepare for a confrontation with protesters, Dec. 22, 2014.

Wan Bao, the Chinese company that runs the mine as part of a joint project, released a statement on its website Tuesday expressing sympathy for the woman who died in the violence Monday.

The company also said most local residents support its plans and that 2 percent of the mine’s profits will go to community development. The local support cited by the company could not be independently verified.

Farmers confront a bulldozer, owned by the Chines mining company, from moving forward as riot police gather at Letpadaung copper mine, Monywa in northwestern Myanmar, Dec. 22, 2014.

Farmers confront a bulldozer, owned by the Chines mining company, from moving forward as riot police gather at Letpadaung copper mine, Monywa in northwestern Myanmar, Dec. 22, 2014.

When reached by VOA, local security officials declined to comment on the situation. Reports have said 11 police were among those injured Monday.

The U.S. State Department told VOA it was deeply concerned about the reports of casualties at the Letpadaung mine. The department said it had urged all parties to exercise restraint, and it called on Burmese authorities to conduct an “expeditious and transparent investigation” into the violence.

Villagers in northern Myanmar lay in front of a bulldozer as part of their bid to stop the controversial expansion of the Chinese-run Letpadaung copper mine, Dec. 22, 2014. (photographer unknown)

Villagers in northern Myanmar lay in front of a bulldozer as part of their bid to stop the controversial expansion of the Chinese-run Letpadaung copper mine, Dec. 22, 2014.

Expansion of the Letpadaung mine has drawn frequent protests from locals, who say they have been unfairly compensated for the land and are worried about the environmental impact of the project.

Earlier this year, two Chinese workers at the mine were briefly kidnapped by local activists. However, they were later released unharmed.

Wan Bao runs the mine together with local companies under a deal that dates to the previous military government.

Farmers confront riot police at the site of the Letpadaung copper mine near Monywa in northwestern Myanmar, Dec. 22, 2014

Farmers confront riot police at the site of the Letpadaung copper mine near Monywa in northwestern Myanmar, Dec. 22, 2014

This report was produced in collaboration with VOA’s Burmese Service.